To date, FDA has approved three next-generation AR inhibitors for nonmetastatic CRPC: apalutamide, enzalutamide, and darolutamide. All three agents improve metastasis-free survival and overall survival. Selection of treatment can be guided by factors such as the patient’s overall health and frailty, potential drug-drug interactions, and the safety profile associated with each agent. This review summarizes the data from the practice-changing SPARTAN, PROSPER, and ARAMIS trials and provides insights on implementation in practice and promotes early intervention with AR inhibitors as standard of care for patients with high-risk nonmetastatic CRPC.