MDLinxWoman Gives Birth Outside Hospital After She Can’t Get Inside. Should Hospitals Set New Standards for Security Staff?

Enhancing Hospital Security Protocols: A Call to Action for Patient Access and Safety

In a recent incident at a Quebec hospital, a security oversight resulted in a woman giving birth outside the facility, highlighting the critical role of hospital security staff in patient safety and access. This event underscores the necessity for clear guidelines and training for security personnel to ensure they can effectively guide patients, especially during emergency situations. The incident serves as a catalyst for hospitals to reevaluate and enhance their security protocols, ensuring that all staff members are equipped to assist patients in accessing the care they need promptly.

Key Points:

• A security guard at a Quebec hospital was terminated following an incident where a woman gave birth outside the hospital due to inaccessible entrances.
• Hospital security personnel in the US are generally not obligated to provide patient care, but they play a crucial role in facilitating access to medical services.
• The incident has prompted the Quebec hospital to improve its signage and employee awareness regarding emergency entrance access during off-hours.
• Dr. Jared Ross emphasizes that, although security guards are not required to perform medical tasks, they have an ethical duty to assist within their training scope.
• The legal framework, as highlighted by the Warren v. District of Columbia case, suggests that security personnel are not legally bound to provide individual protection but are accountable for the broader public safety.
• Hospitals face challenges in standardizing security protocols due to the diversity in hospital sizes and security staff training levels.
• The case highlights the need for hospitals to ensure that security staff are knowledgeable about emergency protocols and can effectively direct patients to the appropriate hospital entrances.

“It is challenging to make any generalizations about the medical or, for that matter, law enforcement training of hospital security. Many smaller hospitals have no security staff, while others have varying levels of training and may or may not be armed.”
– Jared Ross MD, Founder and President of Emergency Medical Services, Education & Consulting (EMSEC)

More on Hospital Operations