MDLinxA Boy’s Heart Stopped for 19 Hours and then it Started Again

Unprecedented Cardiac Arrest Survival in Pediatric Patient Highlights Advances and Mysteries in Cardiac Care

A four-year-old boy in Colorado, Carter McDaniel, miraculously survived a 19-hour cardiac arrest, defying medical expectations. Despite multiple unsuccessful resuscitation attempts, his heart spontaneously restarted, leaving doctors without a scientific explanation.

Key Points:

• Patient Case: Four-year-old Carter McDaniel survived a 19-hour cardiac arrest, an unprecedented duration.
• Resuscitation Efforts: Multiple resuscitation attempts were initially unsuccessful, and medical professionals had little hope for recovery.
• Spontaneous Recovery: McDaniel’s heart began beating again after 19 hours without a clear scientific or medical explanation.
• Parental Perspective: Parents attributed their son’s recovery to divine intervention.
• Cell Death Timeline: Contrary to previous beliefs, newer evidence suggests brain cell death post-cardiac arrest may take hours or even days.
• Cardiac Arrest Statistics:
  • Out-of-Hospital Arrests: More than 365,000 people in the US experience cardiac arrest outside of hospitals annually, with a 60%-80% pre-hospital mortality rate.
  • In-Hospital Arrests: Annually, approximately 292,000 adults and 15,200 children experience in-hospital cardiac arrests.
• Survival Rates:
  • Out-of-Hospital: 11% survival rate among those who receive emergency treatment.
  • In-Hospital: 26% survival rate with hospital discharge.
• Long-term Effects: Survivors may face physical and mental health challenges, including PTSD, memory deficits, cognitive difficulties, anxiety, and depression.
• Positive Outcomes: 10%-20% of survivors report a more altruistic outlook on life.
• Clinical Implications: Emphasizes the importance of seeking immediate medical attention and continued research into cardiac arrest survival mechanisms.

Using a conservative estimate of 200,000 in-hospital cardiac arrests annually in the US, findings from a 2012 NEJM article suggest that an additional 17,200 patients would have survived to hospital discharge in 2009, compared to 2000.

More on Cardiac Arrest