Medical News Today (MNT)Are Plant-based Meat Substitutes Really Better for the Heart than Meat Options?

Comparative Study of Plant-Based Meat Alternatives and Animal-Based Meats Reveals Similar Cardiometabolic Outcomes

A recent study conducted in Singapore assessed the cardiometabolic health effects of plant-based meat analogues (PBMAs) versus traditional animal-based meats (ABMs) among adults at risk for type 2 diabetes. Over an eight-week period, researchers found no significant advantage in heart health benefits for diets incorporating PBMAs compared to those including animal meats. This research underscores the need for careful consideration of nutritional composition when evaluating the health impacts of meat substitutes.

Key Points:

• Study Population and Design: The study involved 89 adults at a higher risk for type 2 diabetes, split into two groups to compare the health impacts of PBMAs and ABMs over an eight-week period.
• Primary Health Outcomes: No significant differences were observed in cholesterol profiles between the two dietary groups; however, some markers of blood sugar levels showed improvement in both groups.
• Blood Pressure and Blood Sugar Management: Participants consuming animal meat displayed better blood sugar management and noted improvements in blood pressure compared to those consuming PBMAs.
• Nutritional Composition: Analysis revealed that PBMAs were higher in sodium, potassium, and calcium, while animal meats provided more protein, which may contribute to the observed differences in blood sugar control.
• Protein Absorption: The study did not examine protein absorption directly, but highlighted concerns about the bioavailability of protein from PBMAs compared to animal meats, which could influence metabolic health markers.
• Health Impact of Sodium and Processed Ingredients: The PBMAs used were high in sodium and contained reheated seed oils, which may negate potential benefits through adverse cardiometabolic effects.
• Implications for Diet Choices: The findings challenge the assumption that all plant-based diets offer similar health benefits, highlighting the discrepancy between whole plant foods and processed plant-based meat substitutes.
• Expert Opinions: Nutrition experts emphasize the importance of whole, minimally processed foods over ultra-processed food options for optimal cardiometabolic health.

“So, despite extensive fortifications of essential nutrients like vitamins B12 and D, iron, and zinc, the negative cardiometabolic effects of sodium and the potential oxidative stress from consuming reheated oils may outweigh any potential benefits from these particular plant-based meat analogues used in this study.”
– Kelsey Costa, MS, RDN

More on Diet & Nutrition