Clinical AdvisorCase Study: Ethics and Mental Illness in Pregnancy

Undisclosed Schizophrenia in Postpartum Woman Raises Ethical and Medical Concerns

A 28-year-old postpartum woman exhibiting erratic behavior was diagnosed with chronic-type schizophrenia, a condition undisclosed by her family. This case highlights the ethical and medical complexities surrounding non-disclosure of mental health conditions, especially in the sensitive postpartum period.

HCN Medical Memo
This case serves as a cautionary tale about the critical importance of obtaining a complete medical history, especially in the postpartum period. Non-disclosure of a serious mental health condition like schizophrenia not only jeopardizes the well-being of the patient but also poses significant risks to the newborn. It also raises ethical questions about informed consent and autonomy, which are paramount in psychiatric care.

Key Points:

• The patient was observed talking to mirrors and neglecting her newborn, leading to psychiatric evaluation.
• The husband revealed that the patient had been diagnosed with schizophrenia years ago, a fact not disclosed to medical staff.
• The patient was nonadherent to her antipsychotic medication, which was secretly administered by her family.
• Physicians’ Perspectives: The case underscores the need for full disclosure of medical history for appropriate care and risk assessment, particularly in the postpartum period.

“This case displayed how the stigma of mental health illness can lead to failure to disclose medical information to clinicians. The patient’s father and husband gave the patient antipsychotic medications without her knowledge to ensure adherence, but failure to disclose this information to the medical staff put the patient’s newborn at risk for neglect and physical harm.”
– Shinu Kuriakose, DHSc, PA-C, Associate Professor in the Department of Physician Assistant Studies New York Institute of Technology, Old Westbury, New York

Additional Points:

• The patient met the DSM-5 criteria for chronic-type schizophrenia.
• Vital signs showed elevated pulse and blood pressure, but other physical examinations were normal.
• The patient responded well to haloperidol treatment and was discharged after one week.
• New Jersey mandates screening for depression in new mothers within 24 hours post-birth, emphasizing the importance of mental health in postpartum care.

More on Medical Ethics