MDLinxNebraska Woman is Suing for Malpractice After Receiving Gender-affirming Care and Double Mastectomy

Luka Hein’s Case Sparks National Debate on Informed Consent and Minors in Gender-Affirming Treatments

In a lawsuit that has ignited conversations among healthcare professionals and policymakers alike, Luka Hein is suing the University of Nebraska Medical Center (UNMC) for gender-affirming treatments she received as a teenager. The case raises critical questions about informed consent, the role of mental health in gender-affirming care, and the ethical responsibilities of healthcare providers.

HCN Medical Memo
The Hein case serves as a cautionary tale about the complexities involved in providing gender-affirming care, especially to minors. It underscores the importance of thorough psychological evaluations and truly informed consent. As debates around legislation like Nebraska’s LB 574 continue, medical professionals must be vigilant in advocating for evidence-based care while also considering the ethical implications of their actions.

Key Points

• Luka Hein, 21, is suing UNMC for gender-affirming treatments, including a double mastectomy she received at 16.
• Hein alleges that UNMC professionals did not adequately address her underlying mental health conditions and pushed for irreversible medical procedures without proper informed consent.
• The lawsuit claims that one physician asked Hein’s parents if they would rather have “a dead daughter or a living son,” although Hein insists she did not express suicidal ideation at the time.
• Hein has become a vocal advocate against gender-affirming care for minors and has testified in support of Nebraska’s LB 574 bill, which will ban such surgeries for minors.
• Major medical organizations like the American Medical Association support access to gender-affirming care, citing low rates of regret among patients.

“Due to widespread misinformation about medical care for transgender and gender-diverse teens, 18 states have passed laws or instituted policies banning gender-affirming care.”
– The Endocrine Society

Additional Points

• Hein’s case is part of her broader political activism, and she is represented by parties known for opposing gender-affirming care.
• Studies indicate that less than 1% of people who received masculinizing or feminizing gender procedures experience regret, compared to higher regret rates in other types of plastic surgery.
• Nebraska Medicine, the entity being sued alongside UNMC, has not commented on the lawsuit.

More on Gender & Sexuality