The New England Journal of Medicine“The Saddest Waste” — Disability, Heredity, and the Artist’s Eye

The Intersection of Art, Medicine, and Social History: Deciphering Joaquín Sorolla’s “¡Triste herencia!”

Joaquín Sorolla’s painting, “¡Triste herencia!” (Sad Inheritance!), serves as a poignant intersection between art, medicine, and societal attitudes towards disability and disease in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Through the lens of this masterful work, the article explores the complex narratives surrounding the health conditions depicted, offering a unique perspective on the intersection of cultural representation and medical understanding. By examining the medical interpretations and social implications of Sorolla’s work, the piece sheds light on the broader contexts of disease, disability, and societal marginalization, providing valuable insights for healthcare professionals.

Key Points:

• Historical Context: Sorolla, known for his ability to capture light, painted “¡Triste herencia!” in 1899, depicting more than 20 disabled boys under the care of a monk, which garnered significant attention and acclaim at the time.
• Medical Interpretations: Recent analyses have connected the physical conditions depicted in the painting to the sequels of a polio epidemic in Valencia, challenging previous interpretations that linked the children’s disabilities to congenital syphilis.
• Societal Implications: The painting reflects the societal attitudes of the time towards disability and disease, showcasing the children as marginalized figures, yet offers them a moment of joy and dignity in their interaction with the natural environment.
• Misinterpretation of Disease: Sorolla originally believed the disabilities to be the result of congenital syphilis, a common assumption of the era, not recognizing the potential link to polio, a disease whose contagious nature was not established until years later.
• Art and Medical Insight: Sorolla’s detailed depiction of muscle wasting and paralysis has been noted for its medical accuracy, particularly in illustrating postpolio paralysis, providing a unique historical insight into the disease’s physical manifestations.
• Social Commentary: Beyond its medical relevance, the painting serves as a social commentary, critiquing the marginalization of disabled individuals and reflecting on the broader implications of disease and disability in society.
• Evolution of Medical Understanding: The article highlights the evolution of medical understanding from the time of Sorolla to the present, emphasizing the significance of art in capturing and influencing perceptions of health and disease.

“One day I was working hard on one of my studies of Valencian fishing, when I discovered from afar a few naked boys in, and on the shore of the sea, and watching over them the vigorous figure of a friar. It seems that they were the residents of the hospital of San Juan de Dios, the saddest waste of society: blind, crazy, crippled and lepers. I cannot explain to you how impressed I was, so much so that I did not waste time to obtain a permit to work in the field, and right there, next to the water’s edge, I made my painting.”
– Joaquín Sorolla

More on Culture & Medicine