The New England Journal of MedicineGuilty

Examining the Role of Residency Training and Systemic Support in Child Abuse Pediatrics: Insights from a Case of Pediatric Sexual Assault

Dr. Monique A. Tello recounts her harrowing experience as a physician-in-training, testifying in a court case involving the sexual assault of a young girl. Her narrative captures the challenges faced by medical trainees in high-stakes situations and highlights the evolution of systemic support and resources for evaluating child victims of sexual abuse. This article serves as a poignant reminder of the importance of proper training, supervision, and systemic support in handling such sensitive cases.

Key Points:

• Court Testimony Experience: Dr. Tello was called to testify in a court case involving the sexual assault of a pediatric patient she had treated.
• Initial Encounter: The assault had occurred nearly a week before the examination, making the use of a rape kit impossible.
• Resource Constraints: Dr. Tello, then an intern, had to conduct the examination with limited guidance and resources.
• Pediatric Rape Case: The patient was a preadolescent girl who described the assault and was examined by Dr. Tello, who documented her findings meticulously.
• Training Gaps: At the time, there were no pediatric Sexual Assault Nurse Examiners (SANE) programs or comprehensive guidelines in place.
• Courtroom Challenge: Dr. Tello’s inexperience was scrutinized by the defense, undermining her credibility despite her detailed documentation.
• Verdict: The defendant was acquitted due to lack of evidence, leaving Dr. Tello feeling guilty and questioning her training.
• Evolution of Support: Since then, there have been significant improvements, including the establishment of guidelines for medical evaluation, pediatric SANE programs, and Children’s Advocacy Centers.
• Specialization: The American Board of Pediatrics now recognizes Child Abuse Pediatrics as a specialty, with trained pediatricians dedicated to this field.
• Residency Training: Despite improvements, the basic structure of residency remains unchanged, with an emphasis on learning from experience and role models.
• Negative Hidden Curriculum: Trainees may still encounter outdated norms that discourage seeking help, which can be detrimental in complex cases.
• Positive Changes: Efforts are underway to study and eradicate negative aspects of medical training, promoting a supportive environment for trainees.

“A few days later, the prosecutor called to tell me that the defendant had been found not guilty on all charges, for lack of evidence. “I don’t think there’s anything you could have done differently,” she reassured me. But I’ve always felt guilty.”
– Dr. Monique A. Tello

More on Child Abuse